Influence.co

Influencer marketing platforms take on a lot of shapes and sizes. There are straight up discovery tools, often described as Google for influencer marketing. There are influencer relationship managers, aka Salesforce for influencer marketing. You can find campaign workflow tools, known as (and you can see where this is going) Asana for influencer marketing. Influence.co can do all of these things, but those tools sit on a platform whose foundation can best be described as LinkedIn for influencer marketing.

It’s a vastly different approach than most platforms take, especially Marketplaces—which, on the surface, is the closest general description of what influence.co does. Most (OK, all) marketplaces that we’ve seen are a variation on the same process: create a campaign brief, broadcast it to whatever influencers are on the platform, wait for them to apply, run a campaign with your chosen few. And, sure, you can do that with influence.co, but it also functions as its own kind of social media platform. We’ll get into how this works in practice in The Details, but for now it’s enough to say that the concept behind influence.co means brands are better able to foster and sustain the sorts of authentic and long-term relationships that are at the heart of influencer marketing. And that’s something that no other marketplace can do (or has even attempted).

Influence.co has been around since 2016, and its three founders—Niel Robertson, Jeff Smith, and Ryan Angilly—built out their company with a long term vision. They’ve seemingly operated in the shadows of the industry, making very few waves or splashes. Their Crunchbase profile is an information wasteland: there are barely any useful details about the company, nor is there much of anything in the way of press coverage or news. With its emphasis on collaboration through community, the founders needed to spend time actually building that out. By design, influence.co becomes more useful, and has more value, as the platform grows larger. It makes sense then they weren’t advertising themselves too heavily in the early years. 

That also makes how much they’ve been able to grow the community doubly impressive. With almost no publicity or marketing, influence.co is now a social network and marketplace with over 250,000 members. Roughly 150,000 of those are the influencers themselves: that’s where the team focused most of their recruiting energy, the classic “If you build it, they will come” philosophy. Influencers are still the platform’s number one priority in terms of acquiring new users. Those influencers share the service with 70,000 businesses, including some very well known brands like Amazon, Jack Daniels, Bumble, and Dyson. The remaining 30,000 accounts are for personal use: people who are neither influencers nor brands. This could be a person who wants to become an influencer but hasn’t got the numbers yet, or it could be someone like—oh, I don’t know, maybe a writer of influencer marketing based content and software reviews who wants to keep his eye on what’s going on in the industry. In this way, influence.co has created something that’s truly unique for the IM software landscape.

Influence.co

Influencer.co takes the idea of an influencer marketplace, and tweaks it ever so slightly to add a social media component. In this way, influencer.co becomes more than a marketplace—it’s a meeting place where influencers and brands can develop actual organic, authentic connections.

Pros and Cons

Social component gives brands a more personalized insight into influencers

Community-focused platform drives/supports authenticity

Many rave reviews from users

Campaign reporting is extremely basic

Influencers author their own profiles rather than relying on data

Best for: Small and Medium Brands

Ratings

Features

4.5

Ease of Use

5.0

Reporting

4.0

Overall Score:

4.5

Summary:

Pricing

Influence.co works off a freemium model, and it does this in an easy and transparent way. There are only two plans: one that’s free and one that isn’t.

• Business Basics, $0/month — With the basic account, you can build your own profile and access the influence.co community. You can do basic searches with up to 50 results per search, and organize those results in up to 3 lists. You’ll get standard demographics for influencers. You can create and publish campaigns on the platform, get unlimited applications,  and message with up to 12 influencers per month as you decide if you’d like to work with them.
• Business Pro, $600/mo (minimum 6 months) — With a Pro account, you get multiple profiles, advanced searches, unlimited results, unlimited lists, advanced search (including by demographics), unlimited campaigns, campaign management, campaign reports, team members and campaign promotion (i.e. lead sourcing).

Influencers also have a couple of options for their accounts:

• Basic, $0/month — Influencers on the free plan can set up a full profile on the site, contact 5 other members per week, apply to 5 brand campaigns per week, 50 results per search, up to 3 lists of other influencers, brands, and agencies, and get access to their Instagram followers’ demographics.
• Pro, $4/month (billed annually) — Influencers with a Pro account get 30 member contacts/month, 30 brand campaigns/month, unlimited results and lists, Instagram follower data, see who’s viewed their profile.

For both influencers and brands, paying for the Pro plan puts a “PRO” badge on their profile (or should we say PRO-file? [hashtag dad jokes]). 

The Details

If you’re at all familiar with influencer marketing software, you might be wondering how a marketplace platform could double as a social channel. There’s an inherent community to social networks, while marketplaces have a more mercenary quality to them. Brands and influencers alike are only there for themselves, and trying to negotiate their best prices. Where does the community fit in?

This is why the creators of influence.co refer to it as the LinkedIn for influencer marketing. There is, of course, the job seeking element to it:  with over 600 live campaigns, brands are trying to find creators to collaborate with, creators are trying to find brands that want to work with them. Meanwhile, the social feed is populated with all kinds of content: influencers can post as a way to show their worth; brands share content or open campaigns; brands can ask for input from influencers, maybe advice on what works and what doesn’t. There’s also content created and published by the online influencer culture magazine nofilter. It’s run by influence.co, but don’t think that it’s just a cynical attempt at adding value. They’re taking nofilter seriously, putting out some legit content and recently hiring former Rolling Stone and Billboard editor Nick Catucci. 

Community feedback

The nofilter publication

Because of the social media functions, influencers are able to create much more thorough profiles for themselves and really showcase their work. With most marketplaces, an influencer profile is automatically populated with data and content that’s ingested through the API. Here, the influencer has a greater degree of control over the profile, able to write their own bio and create a portfolio of their past collaborations across any of their connected profiles. Standard demographic information is shown by default, and brands/agencies with Pro accounts can look at the more advanced demographics that are part of the first-party data influence.co receives via API.

Influencer-built profiles

Brands and agencies can also create their own profiles, which work like a company page on LinkedIn. Employees of these companies create their own profiles, and become team members for the brand—giving them the ability to post as the company and collaborate on campaigns.

It’s important to understand the primary function of the social aspect of influence.co: it doesn’t take the place of discovery and activation, it complements it. As with any influencer, engagement and authenticity matters. When they’re liking and commenting on posts, brands see influencers as motivated, willing to put in the effort. And while brands can absolutely post their open campaigns to their profiles (and therefore the feed), there are also more traditional methods of doing so. They can use the search function to find influencers by standard criteria like category, followers counts, and social channel. But they can also search for more unconventional things like past collaborations (maybe with a brand’s competitor), or whether or not they have an Amazon influencer shop.

Campaign application management

Creating campaign briefs on influence.co will also be a familiar experience for anyone who’s worked with a marketplace before. You can create detailed campaign briefs spelling out your objectives and requirements, accept applications, and message back and forth with influencers who do apply. If you’re on the free plan, this is where your features end. You can still run campaigns outside the platform, using whatever software (or none at all) to manage them as posts go live. For those paying for the Business Pro plan, you’ll get access to the campaign management tools for handling all the applications, communicating with team members, and finalising content for everything to go live.

End-to-end workflow

Finally, there’s the reporting on your campaigns (for Pro accounts). This is actually the one downer in a series of bright spots. The information you get out of influence.co is minimal, consisting only of publicly available data: total likes, total comments, and a catalog of all the content that’s part of the campaign. You can sort the content by newest/oldest, or most/least popular. And that’s essentially it. No visualisations of the data that it does have, no analysis of when and where and who is engaging. It’s surprisingly lean for a platform that excels at everything else.

Reporting integrated into workflow

Conclusion

We’ve covered a lot of different influencer marketplaces as part of our platform reviews here, and until now they have all been different implementations of the same process, some doing it better than others. If you go back and read the other reviews, you can play a drinking game with the number of times there’s some variation of the phrase “as you’d expect”—as in “Search works just as you’d expect,” etc. Much of influence.co’s more traditional marketplace function works as you’d expect, as well.

What is unexpected is the social foundation that props everything else up. This succeeds in elevating the platform to something else entirely. Brands can search for influencers easy enough, but it’s more likely the ones they find organically, the ones who are interacting with posts up and down the feed, will end up in the kind of long term brand/creator relationship that is what makes influencer marketing so effective. If you want to market to your audience authentically, driving users to become your customers and organically spreading the word, then finding those influencers in the same way seems the logical choice. It’s social media marketing for social media marketers looking to improve their social marketing. 

The transactional nature of the influencer marketplace is turned upside down with influence.co with the creation of a communal and collaborative social space focused on a specific audience. Anyone can participate in the social aspect of it for free, so even if you’re using other software this is an excellent way to discover new talent, and can complement your existing methods without complicating or compromising them. If it weren’t for the minimal data in the campaign reporting, this would be 5 star software. The more people sign on to the community, the more effective influence.co becomes. And as more brands and agencies see that effectiveness, they’ll want to migrate fully over and make the platform their go-to professional network and campaign management tool.

Influencer campaign briefs

Search branded content

Eight types of search