- TikTok Shop’s third round of layoffs reflects its struggle to adapt Chinese-style in-stream commerce for Western audiences.
- Cultural friction: users separate entertainment from shopping, hampering conversion despite high livestream viewership.
- Reorganization leans on veterans from Douyin and a leaner core team to iterate more quickly.
- Future focus on narrative-driven creator partnerships and data-informed pilots over one-off sales events.
- Brands and influencers must shift from transactional pushes to authentic, ongoing product storytelling to drive results.
Despite tripling U.S. Black Friday sales, TikTok’s Shop division failed to hit 2024 performance goals, triggering its third round of cuts.
When TikTok first launched its in-app shopping platform in the West, it tapped into its enormous user base to replicate the runaway success of its Chinese counterpart. Now, on the heels of its third round of staff reductions, it’s clear that translating live-streamed commerce thrills into sustained growth for Western audiences remains an uphill battle.
A Bold Ambition Meets Cultural Reality
TikTok’s parent company envisioned the Shop division as more than just an add-on to its hugely popular short-form video feed. It saw a chance to embed purchasing opportunities directly into users’ everyday scroll. Early promotions highlighted flash-sale events, themed shopping festivals, and collaborations with well-known brands—efforts designed to spark impulse buys and create a seamless bridge between discovery and purchase.
@tiktokshop_us TikTok Shop’s biggest sale is here! 🔥 Up to 60% OFF the hottest finds. Shop now before they’re gone. #DealsForYouDays #DealsForEveryYou
Behind the scenes, executives charted an aggressive roadmap. They believed that by layering in livestreamed demonstrations, in-video product tags, influencer-driven discount codes, and new badges, they could alter long-standing Western shopping habits.
After all, Chinese consumers had flocked to livestreamed marketplaces in droves. Could the same strategy captivate audiences accustomed to dedicated shopping apps and desktop e-commerce sites?
A Third Round of Cuts
Despite enthusiastic rollouts in multiple countries and partnerships with marquee retailers, the Shop team repeatedly fell short of internal projections. Earlier this year, a fresh wave of role eliminations swept through product, marketing, and operations teams, marking the third downsizing since the division’s inception.
Staffers across product management and creator partnerships received notices that their positions were being eliminated or consolidated under new leadership.
The mood among affected employees ranged from stunned to resigned. Many had invested months crafting shopping-specific features and forging relationships between brands and emerging TikTok creators. Now they faced abrupt departures or the uncertainty of reassignment, even as company leaders expressed confidence that a leaner structure would sharpen focus and speed decision-making.
When Livestream Mania Collides with Western Habits
One of the core challenges has been cultural: Western consumers tend to view video and shopping as separate activities.
On TikTok, users come for entertainment and social connection. When new shopping features interrupt that flow, friction emerges. Even high-profile livestream events, which racked up millions of viewers, seldom translated into a proportional number of completed purchases.
Contrast this with markets where in-app buying feels natural: audiences there assign the same app for discovery, conversation, and transaction. On TikTok Shop in the West, however, shoppers still prefer to research products on dedicated platforms or read detailed reviews before hitting “buy.”
Bridging that gap has proven more complex than anticipated, and raising adoption rates will likely require more than flashy campaigns—it demands a fundamental re-imagination of the browsing experience.
Check out the TikTok Eyes Japan for E-Commerce Push: A Key Move in Its Global Social Commerce Strategy
Reorganization and a New Playbook
In response to these stumbles, TikTok has shifted resources toward a smaller core team empowered to make rapid product tweaks. Executive leadership has reached back to experts from its Chinese operations to advise on integrating commerce features more organically into the feed.
A fresh emphasis on deep analytics aims to pinpoint exactly how and when users are inclined to click through from video to purchase.
Similarly, partnerships with content creators are being retooled. Rather than broadcasting generic shopping events, TikTok is encouraging more authentic, narrative-driven promotions, where creators weave sponsored products naturally into their day-to-day content. The hope is that long-term trust built by these micro-moments will outlast the hype cycle of one-off livestream spectacles.
Implications for Influencers and Brands
For influencers, the shifting priorities mean that performance metrics tied to direct sales are no longer the sole yardstick. Brands now look for creators who can cultivate ongoing dialogues around products, share in-depth demonstrations, and foster genuine community input.
Those who successfully embrace this advisory role may find themselves in higher demand, while purely transactional shout-outs risk being cut from future campaigns.
Brands, too, are recalibrating expectations. Rather than hammering out large-scale partnerships expecting immediate spikes in revenue, they’re experimenting with segmented pilots—limited-run collaborations that test concepts in tight demographics before scaling.
Forever Sundays is one brand that has managed to crack the code around influencer collaborations on TikTok Shop. Through the use of trusted voices that perfectly match their core audiences, they've cemented themselves as the World’s 1st Tanning Contour Stick on TikTok.
@mayalawlor 🤍 #fyp #grwm #nighttimeroutine #lashes #grwmforbed @Foreversundays @BEAUTY BAY @Coco & Eve US
This experimentation may slow the pace of deals, but it promises a more sustainable integration of commerce into the TikTok ecosystem.
Broader Lessons and the Road Ahead
TikTok’s third round of Shop layoffs underscores a broader truth about digital commerce: success in one market does not guarantee success in another without careful adaptation. Simply transplanting a formula from China overlooked the unique behaviors of Western users.
Now, with a leaner team and tighter focus on community-driven experiences, TikTok Shop has the chance to iterate more nimbly.
In the coming months, watch for smarter creator collaborations, streamlined in-video buying paths, and possibly new incentives—such as loyalty perks—for users who embrace in-app purchases. The journey from entertainment platform to full-blown marketplace remains unfinished, but the latest reorganization reveals a willingness to learn, adapt, and persevere.
While third time’s not always the charm, TikTok Shop’s leadership appears determined to spark a fourth wave of innovation—proof that in the fast-paced world of social commerce, resilience and reinvention are the keys to eventual triumph.
