Influencer marketing can produce incredible results for brands that use it well. Influencer Marketing Hub undertook a survey in 2017 and discovered that the respondents had received a return of $7.65 for every dollar they spent on influencer marketing. However, the results varied. The top 15% received more than $20 for every influencer dollar spent, but 25% either lost money or just broke even. One reason for firms losing money was because they picked poor influencers. They didn't check the authenticity of their influencers or whether they had audience credibility.
As influencer marketing becomes more popular, almost mainstream, influencer selection becomes even more pivotal to a campaign’s success. However, the main prerequisite for a campaign to work is that it uses genuine influencers to spread the brand’s message. There are unscrupulous people online who like the reputation and perks of being considered an influencer, without doing the work needed to reach that status. Moreover, some companies have had their campaigns come unstuck because of these pseudo-influencers.
In short, an influencer has to influence people, have their respect and encourage them to take action. If an “influencer” can’t do that, then they are unworthy of the title.
Influencers Marketing Hub’s Audience Credibility Checker [Instagram Audience Credibility Checker], can help you spot fake or misstated accounts on Instagram. We take an Instagram account and analyze its content and activity to establish how credible it is. This tool helps you decide whether the claimed audience of an “influencer” are real people who engage with and take a genuine interest in this person’s posts.
FREE Instagram Bot Analytics Tool [Audience Credibility Checker]
Take away much of your worry about the credibility of potential influencers. You can enter any influencer's Instagram handle into the Instagram Bot Analytics Tool [Audience Credibility Checker] and it will give you an excellent guide to the genuineness of the account.
Please also refer to the note below this tool.
The above tool is an Audience Credibility Checker (not a fake follower checker) - this means the credibility of the audience engagement is measured. ie. a high credibility score does not necessarily indicate "real followers" - the account may still have bought fake followers, the engagement rate could be very low but those few engagements are real and therefore the credibility score could still be above 80.
The tool takes into account factors such as the account's avatar, number of accounts followed vs following ratio, following, number of posts, number of likes received vs number of likes ratio in an attempt to establish the audience credibility score of the Instagram account. Influencer Marketing Hub does not guarantee the accuracy of these results - we provide access to these tools in an attempt to enable more transparency in the industry.
You should find that any real influencers who work at ensuring their audience is genuine, will attain scores of 80 or above. Anybody who scores poorly would be of little value to your business, and a potential waste of your investment if you were to pay them to promote your product or service.
Most People Suffer From Fake Instagram Followers
The days are long gone since you could say, “It must be true – I read it on the internet.” You cannot just assume that if somebody claims they large numbers of followers on Instagram, that these people take any interest in the person’s account – or indeed that these followers are real people at all.
Unscrupulous people boost their follower numbers by buying followers. Sometimes these are real people, happy to earn extra cash. Other times these are fake accounts set up by bots. No matter how they are created, the fake followers will not engage with the “influencer’s” posts in any way and are of no value to a brand wanting to work with him or her.
Instagram (or indeed the other social networks) cannot eliminate all fake accounts. Determined scammers will always find a way around any security mechanisms Instagram can put in place. So it is up to brands (and indeed genuine influencers) to hunt out and find fake followers.
It is important to remember that it is not just people wanting to inflate their follower lists who have fake followers. Virtually everybody on Instagram has some. This includes genuine influencers (and probably your own account). That is why it is unlikely that our Audience Credibility Checker [Bot Checker] will show your account as having 100% credible followers. Even our Influencer Marketing Hub Instagram account can't quite make an Audience Credibility Score of 100 (it was 99.21% when we last checked), and we make scrupulous checks to ensure only genuine accounts follow us.
Why People Buy Followers
Some people mistakenly think that the most important factor for social media success is the number of followers somebody has. So, they try to take a shortcut to their success and pay to buy followers. They equate the number of followers you display with your level of popularity.
However, that is not how social media works. Anybody can buy followers. But, you will not be an influencer unless you can influence people. You need to become a thought leader in your niche, and organically build your following.
The problem with buying followers is that it gives you a very unbalanced account. You have thousands of followers, but little engagement. The only person you influence is yourself, and it is not that hard for anyone analyzing your account to spot what you have done.
Signs of a Fake Follower
The easiest way to spot a fake follower is to enter their account name into our Audience Credibility Checker / Bot Checker. Although most people won’t have perfect scores here, you will notice accounts with particularly low credibility scores.
But what makes a fake follower? How can you say somebody isn’t a genuine follower? Here are some of the danger signs to look for in an Instagram account.
1. An account has “unusual” numbers.
Genuine accounts tend to have similar patterns when it comes to numbers of followers, people followed, and levels of engagement. Although everybody operates their accounts differently, and some “newbies” don’t run their accounts like seasoned Instagrammers, you can still easily spot outliers.
For instance, they may like and follow thousands of people, but don’t have many following them in return. Perhaps they don’t make many if any, posts themselves. This doesn’t necessarily mean that they are a bot, but it does suggest that will be of little value as a follower. They definitely don’t influence anybody.
Genuine influencers will have more followers than accounts they follow – often by a substantial margin. For instance, we recently looked at the Top 10 Instagram fitness models. Sommer Ray tops that list. She has 18.2 million followers, but only follows 264 accounts in return. Even the 10th person on our list, Izabel Goulart, has a one-sided ratio: 4.2 million followers to 340 accounts followed. An ordinary Instagrammer may have a rate closer to 1:1, but nobody (apart from perhaps a complete “newbie”) should have substantially more accounts followed than followers.
Similarly, you should look at a potential influencer’s engagement rate. A quality influencer will have engagement (likes and comments) of about 1.5-3% of their followers, e.g., if an influencer has 100,000 followers, you should see 1,500 – 3,000 likes and comments (combined) on an average post. An engagement rate of 1 percent is okay for many influencers, depending on their niche. If an “influencer’s” engagement rate for his/her posts is regularly well below than this, you should be suspicious, however.
Don’t think higher is necessarily better, however. An engagement rate of 10 percent plus could be suspicious. If you see engagement rates that high, the influencer could be using artificial engagement techniques, such as being part of an engagement group (influencers work together, commenting and liking each other’s posts to boost their statistics).
2. A lot of action for a few days, but then little other activity.
Often somebody will create a bot that follows hundreds or thousands of people on the day of its creation. It may even share some content on that day to make it look genuine. Once the bot has followed sufficient people, it stops and relies on people not checking their accounts and unfollowing the fake account.
Genuine influencers tend to have relatively steady growth in their follower numbers. The rate of increase may grow once they are recognized as an influencer, but they will not have a massive burst of followers in a short period of time (as most fake accounts do).
3. Empty, Hidden or Copied Profile Sections
People creating fake accounts usually don’t put much effort into creating realistic-sounding bios. Sometimes they just leave the bio section blank, or they just fill in the minimum details. They sometimes even adjust the settings to make the profile hidden. This makes your investigation harder, as you can't see their details. You should ask yourself, however, how genuine is somebody who hides their bio details. Are they likely to make an engaging, dedicated follower?
Similarly, you should consider a lack of a profile picture to be a red flag, particularly in a visual medium like Instagram.
In some cases, unscrupulous Instagrammers “catfish” you by creating totally fake bios, often using somebody else’s picture. These are frequently just images picked up from stock photo sites.
4. Spammy, Irrelevant and Clueless Comments
Some of the smarter bot accounts (and even some of the more dishonest human-operated accounts) create comments to make them appear genuine. The problem is that these comments are generic and lack substance. For instance, you might spot that an account continually comments “good picture” or “good job.”
While these comments are technically engagement, they have no value to a brand that is hoping for an influencer to persuade his / her followers that the brand’s product will be suitable for them.
Likewise, some accounts leave irrelevant spam comments, obviously trying to sell something. Sometimes these are poorly thought through and executed sales tactics. In other cases they are more sinister, encouraging you to leave contact information, so they steal your identity.