Home Influencer Marketing how cometeer creators tastings make frozen coffee worth trying
Preview for How Cometeer Used Creators and Tastings to Make Frozen Coffee Worth Trying

How Cometeer Used Creators and Tastings to Make Frozen Coffee Worth Trying

Coffee brands have spent decades telling consumers that fresh is better. Cometeer asks them to believe that some of the best coffee comes frozen.

The Massachusetts-based company works with specialty roasters, brews their coffee into a concentrated liquid, and flash-freezes it in aluminum capsules. Customers simply melt the coffee into hot water or milk, or use it to make iced drinks. No grinder, espresso machine, or brewing skills required.

The convenience is obvious once someone understands the product. Convincing people to try frozen coffee in the first place is another challenge. Cometeer needed to overcome assumptions about freshness, justify its premium positioning, and introduce a completely different coffee routine.

Instead of relying exclusively on advertising, the company combined physical sampling, creator recommendations, expert-led tastings, and experiences that encouraged customers to discover their own preferences.

The goal was to make an unfamiliar product something people could understand, experience, and eventually recommend themselves.


Why Frozen Coffee Needed More Than a Good Explanation

Cometeer's origins trace back to co-founder Matthew Roberts experimenting with frozen coffee while studying abroad in Spain. Missing the iced coffee he regularly drank at home, Roberts began freezing brewed coffee and exploring whether the process could preserve its flavor.

His early experiments eventually led him to specialty coffee pioneer George Howell, who introduced him to coffees that tasted radically different from the mass-market blends Roberts knew.

In a factory documentary, Roberts recalls returning to frozen samples brewed from Howell's coffee 6 months earlier. The results convinced him that freezing could preserve qualities that would ordinarily deteriorate during storage.

Cometeer developed that concept into a manufacturing process that uses precision brewing and liquid nitrogen to freeze concentrated coffee shortly after extraction. The company also had to introduce an entirely new way of consuming coffee.

Traditional capsules require a machine. Whole beans require grinding and brewing. Instant coffee dissolves in water. Cometeer arrives already brewed, but frozen.

Roberts summarized the positioning during a Subscription Scaled podcast interview. "Everyone can melt the perfect cup. Not everyone can brew the perfect cup."

The statement captured the product's appeal while exposing its marketing problem.

Customers weren't necessarily looking for a new coffee format. They were looking for a convenient way to enjoy coffee they liked.

As Roberts explained, introducing the technology first could complicate the conversation. The brand needed to show people how to make their preferred drinks, let them experience the taste, and then explain why the process worked.

Cometeer's challenge was therefore bigger than awareness. It needed to build confidence in a product that sounded unusual before customers had the opportunity to taste it.


Cometeer Made Tasting the First Step Toward Trust

Cometeer's experiential marketing efforts followed a straightforward principle. Give customers the opportunity to experience the coffee before expecting them to subscribe.

In September 2022, the brand demonstrated how quickly it could turn a cultural moment into a sampling opportunity. After Goldman Sachs reportedly removed complimentary cold brew from its offices, Cometeer's team organized a pop-up outside the bank's New York headquarters.

According to Inc.'s account of the stunt, the team assembled the activation in approximately 16 hours, bringing coffee capsules, oat milk, and supplies to serve around 100 employees.

The stunt attracted attention because it responded to a specific consumer frustration. More importantly, it introduced Cometeer through the product itself. The company later expanded that approach into more structured tasting experiences.

In 2023, Cometeer partnered with coffee expert James Hoffmann on the Great American Coffee Taste Test.

The initiative involved 5,000 consumers tasting 4 different coffees and recording their preferences.

According to Cometeer's findings, only 55% of participants' stated roast preferences matched their blind-tasting choices.

The company-produced research gave Cometeer a reason to encourage experimentation. Customers who assumed they preferred dark roasts might discover they enjoyed lighter, fruitier coffees.

Rather than telling people what premium coffee should taste like, Cometeer invited them to make their own comparisons. The same thinking influenced the company's mall kiosks.

In an Above the Fold YouTube interview, Cometeer brand manager Olivia Laskowski explained how staff offered complimentary coffee tailored to each visitor's preferences.

While preparing the drink, staff demonstrated the frozen capsules, explained the process, and introduced a subscription offer available specifically at the kiosk.

Laskowski described the kiosks as the company's strongest acquisition channel at the time of the interview.

A TikTok creator independently documented that experience. After encountering a Cometeer kiosk outside a closed Starbucks at Short Hills Mall, she tried the coffee and signed up for a subscription.

Her subsequent video showed how she prepared it at home.

The interaction captures Cometeer's approach. A complimentary cup introduced the product, while the creator's subsequent recommendation gave other consumers a reason to investigate it.

The company's progress was not uninterrupted. Forbes reported layoffs, leadership changes, and slowing subscription growth in January 2023. Its later campaigns demonstrate continued experimentation, rather than proving a financial turnaround.


Coffee Experts Became Part of the Product Experience

As Cometeer developed its marketing strategy, partnerships became opportunities to introduce different audiences to specialty coffee.

Some collaborations connected the product to established cultural personalities. Others placed coffee expertise directly inside the experience customers purchased.

In February 2024, Cometeer partnered with Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg through their lifestyle brand Houseplant.

The collaboration introduced 2 coffee roasts, Bean There Done That and Get Roasted, selected to reflect the founders' preferences. In an interview with Food & Wine, Rogen described how the team sampled numerous coffees before settling on the final selections.

The partnership connected Cometeer to Houseplant's audience through a product its founders had helped develop.

The following year, Cometeer expanded its relationship with James Hoffmann through an even more education-focused collaboration.

Launched in August 2025, the James Hoffmann Discovery Kit contained 16 capsules representing 8 coffees selected to introduce different flavor profiles, roast styles, and origins.

The collection included coffees from respected roasters such as Onyx Coffee Lab, Intelligentsia, Proud Mary, Black & White, and George Howell.

Hoffmann also created accompanying tasting videos. In his promotional video, he explains how customers can prepare each coffee while watching him discuss its origins, flavor characteristics, and different ways to enjoy it.

The experience helped participants identify the qualities they enjoyed most instead of relying on familiar roast labels.

The distinction matters for creator marketing. Hoffmann contributed expertise that became part of the product's value. Customers weren't simply buying coffee associated with a recognizable personality. They were purchasing a guided experience designed around his knowledge.

Cometeer applied similar thinking to partnerships with specialty roasters.

In its Black & White Roasters collaboration video, the teams taste several coffees while discussing sourcing, roasting, and the flavors that distinguish individual selections.

Black & White's director of roasting, Matt Ferraro, explains how the partnership makes challenging specialty coffees easier to enjoy without customers worrying about making brewing mistakes.

The accompanying content introduces the people responsible for the coffee while demonstrating what makes their work distinctive.

Across these collaborations, Cometeer used different kinds of credibility. Houseplant brought cultural relevance. Hoffmann provided expert guidance. Specialty roasters supplied product knowledge and an established reputation within the coffee community.

Each partnership gave customers another way to understand what made Cometeer's coffee worth exploring.


Everyday Creators Made Frozen Coffee Feel Familiar

Expert collaborations helped establish credibility, but Cometeer also needed to show how its product worked outside carefully curated tasting experiences. Everyday creators filled that role.

In his Subscription Scaled interview, Roberts described an approach built around testing multiple creators, identifying effective partnerships, and developing deeper relationships with those who performed well.

The company experimented with paid placements and revenue-sharing arrangements. Roberts also discussed the possibility of giving creators personalized coffee selections or involving them in sourcing.

He emphasized that the product's secondary benefits could change depending on the audience. Fitness creators might emphasize convenience and caffeine. Food creators could demonstrate recipes. Coffee enthusiasts could explain flavor and preparation.

Content across TikTok illustrates how those different approaches translate into practical recommendations. One creator opened his video by explaining that he had used Cometeer for 6 months before agreeing to a paid partnership.

He then demonstrated his regular iced latte recipe, using milk, honey syrup, and a frozen coffee capsule.

The disclosure gave context to his recommendation. He was promoting the product commercially, but described an existing personal routine that preceded the partnership.

Other creators presented Cometeer through experiences unrelated to sponsorships.

A working mother described using the capsules to simplify her mornings. Another creator showed how she prepared a latte every day without owning a coffee machine, explicitly stating that her recommendation was not an advertisement.

Some videos demonstrated how word of mouth could create interest beyond the original audience.

In one example, a creator explained that she had repeatedly noticed another woman's frozen coffee capsules in TikTok videos. After identifying the brand, she searched for Cometeer at a nearby Sprouts store and documented her shopping trip.

The video illustrates how routine content can prompt product discovery even when the creator isn't producing a dedicated advertisement.

Cometeer's Instagram presence reflects a similar range of use cases. We used HypeAuditor and identified 55 Instagram mentions from 44 creators, including 37 posts classified as organic.

The creators represented categories such as family, lifestyle, baking, and food rather than exclusively specialty coffee.

One paid partnership with creator @_joytothefood_ incorporated Cometeer into a chocolate chunk protein muffin recipe. The creator explained the frozen coffee format, included a promotional code, and encouraged followers to request the recipe.

View this post on Instagram

The product appeared naturally alongside the breakfast content her audience already followed.

Not every independent review was enthusiastic. Some creators praised the taste but preferred grinding beans themselves, while others questioned the price, freezer storage requirements, or differences from traditional espresso.

Those reservations reveal an important distinction in Cometeer's positioning.

The capsules appealed to people who wanted good coffee with less preparation. They weren't necessarily intended to replace the brewing process for enthusiasts who enjoyed that ritual.


Cometeer Turned Coffee Discovery Into Something Customers Could Share

Cometeer's later campaigns extended the idea of guided discovery into experiences customers could complete and discuss themselves. In 2026, the company introduced the World Mug Collection, a limited-edition coffee tournament featuring 16 coffees from 16 countries.

Customers received 32 capsules, with 2 of each coffee, and compared them through head-to-head tastings. Instead of simply sampling an assortment, participants advanced their favorite coffees through a tournament bracket.

They could record their preferences in the Cometeer app, select a winner, and build a personalized coffee profile based on the origins, roast styles, and flavors they preferred.

In a LinkedIn announcement, Roberts stated that the team had tasted more than 500 single-origin coffees while developing the collection.

The World Mug experience turned the customer into an active participant. People weren't only purchasing coffee. They were comparing flavors, making choices, and discovering something about their preferences.

The company's Advent Calendars used a related approach. Each day introduced a different coffee, encouraging repeated tasting and giving customers an opportunity to explore roasters and flavor profiles throughout the holiday season.

Cometeer also worked to make existing customers part of its acquisition strategy. Roberts explained that its referral programs offered rewards ranging from subscription credits and merchandise to access to rare coffees.

Loyal subscribers could also receive credits to gift a free box to someone else.

During his interview, he identified referrals as the company's leading acquisition channel at that time.

The referral initiatives operated separately from campaigns such as World Mug, but they served a related purpose. Both encouraged people to share their experiences with coffee rather than simply repeat the brand's advertising claims.

Taken together, these activities show how Cometeer created multiple opportunities for discovery. Customers could encounter the product through a creator, experience it at a kiosk, participate in an expert-led tasting, or receive their first box from a friend.

Each interaction offered a different reason to give frozen coffee a chance.


The First Taste Was Only the Beginning

Cometeer's marketing challenge started with a product that seemed to contradict what consumers already believed about good coffee.

Its response was to make that product easier to understand through demonstrations, trusted recommendations, and firsthand experiences.

Coffee experts helped explain quality. Everyday creators showed how the capsules fit into familiar routines. Interactive collections gave customers opportunities to discover their preferences, while referral programs encouraged them to introduce the product to others.

The lesson for marketers extends beyond coffee.

When a product requires consumers to change their assumptions, awareness alone isn't enough. The most valuable creators and campaigns are often the ones that help people experience the difference for themselves.

About the Author
Kalin Anastasov plays a pivotal role as an content manager and editor at Influencer Marketing Hub. He expertly applies his SEO and content writing experience to enhance each piece, ensuring it aligns with our guidelines and delivers unmatched quality to our readers.